Disclosure: Fency Music, linked on this page, is our sister store. Liverpool Music does not currently earn affiliate commission from any retailer mentioned here.

Ask why a Strat sounds different from a Les Paul and most guitarists will give you the same answer: pickups. Body shape, wood and scale length all play a part, but the pickups are the first thing your strings talk to, and they shape almost everything you hear afterwards. Choosing between single coils and humbuckers is one of the earliest decisions a new electric player makes, often without realising it.

I am a songwriter, and I build FencyGuitar, a guitar learning app, so I think about pickups in terms of what they do to a song: whether chords ring clearly, whether a riff sounds heavy, and whether the guitar inspires you to keep playing. This guide explains how each type works, how they sound, and which suits the music you want to make. Prices are UK prices checked in late October 2026.

The Quick Answer

If your songs live on clean or lightly driven chords, single coils will flatter them. If they start with a riff and a loud amp, humbuckers will make you sound finished sooner. If you cannot decide, a guitar with both, such as an HSS Strat, covers most ground.

What a Pickup Actually Does

A pickup is a magnet wrapped in thousands of turns of very thin copper wire. Your steel strings vibrate inside the magnetic field, and that movement creates a small electrical signal in the coil. The signal travels through the volume and tone controls, out of the jack and into your amp.

How many turns of wire, what kind of magnet and how many coils there are all change the result. More wire usually means more output and a warmer, more compressed sound. A stronger magnet adds output and attack. And the number of coils is the big difference between the two types in this guide.

Pickups do not create tone out of nothing. They react to the strings, the wood and your hands. But they act like a filter on everything that comes before them, which is why swapping pickups can transform a guitar more than any other single change.

Single Coil Pickups

A single coil pickup has one coil of wire around a row of magnets. Leo Fender's designs made it famous: the Telecaster arrived in the early 1950s and the Stratocaster followed in 1954, and both used single coils.

The sound. Single coils are bright and clear, with a quick attack and plenty of detail in the high frequencies. Chords sound open and separated, so you hear each string. Funk rhythm parts snap, clean arpeggios sparkle, and lightly driven blues has a biting edge. On a Strat, positions two and four on the five way switch combine two pickups for the hollow, slightly quacky tone that so many records use.

The catch: hum. A single coil also works as an aerial for electrical noise. In the UK that shows up as a 50Hz hum from mains wiring, dimmer switches, laptops and fridges. Clean, it is often barely noticeable. Add a lot of gain and the hum rises with it. On a Strat, positions two and four are usually wired so the two pickups cancel most of the hum, which is one reason players love them.

Typical guitars. The Squier Sonic Stratocaster, at £159 at guitarguitar when I checked, uses three ceramic single coils. The Squier Classic Vibe '50s Stratocaster, at £399, uses alnico single coils designed by Fender, which sound warmer and smoother. Our Squier vs Epiphone comparison covers both.

Humbucker Pickups

A humbucker uses two coils side by side, wired so that the hum picked up by one is cancelled by the other, while the string signal from both adds together. Seth Lover developed the design at Gibson in the mid 1950s, and early examples carried a "Patent Applied For" sticker, which is why vintage style humbuckers are still called PAFs.

The sound. Humbuckers are warmer, thicker and louder than single coils. Because the two coils sense the strings at slightly different points, some of the sharpest high frequencies cancel out, which smooths the top end. Power chords sound big, single note riffs have weight, and the guitar pushes an amp harder, so it breaks up sooner.

The catch: less sparkle. The same smoothing that helps under distortion can make clean chords sound a little thick or muddy, especially on a dark amp. Some players find humbuckers less expressive at very low gain.

Typical guitars. The Epiphone Les Paul Standard '50s, at £499 to £549 when I checked, uses ProBucker humbuckers. A Gibson Les Paul Standard '50s uses Burstbuckers. Our Gibson vs Epiphone Les Paul comparison explains what changes between the two, and if you already own a Les Paul style guitar, our guide to the best Les Paul pickups covers upgrades.

P90s: The Middle Ground

There is a third type worth knowing. The P90 is a single coil pickup, but a wide one, with more wire and a different magnet arrangement than a Fender style single coil. Gibson introduced it in the 1940s, before the humbucker existed.

P90s sound thicker and grittier than Strat pickups and more open than humbuckers. They break up into a raw, punchy overdrive that punk, garage and indie players love. They still hum, though, because they are single coils. The Epiphone Les Paul Junior, at £359 to £429 when I checked, is an affordable way to hear one.

How They Compare Under Gain

The biggest practical difference shows up when you add distortion.

Clean. Single coils usually win for clarity. Chords ring, and the guitar responds instantly to your picking hand.

Light crunch. Both sound great. Single coils give a biting, spanky edge; humbuckers give a rounder, more compressed crunch. This is where taste matters most.

High gain. Humbuckers win. They stay quiet and full, and the low end stays tight. Single coils can sound thin and fizzy, and the hum gets loud.

Your pedals matter too. A Tube Screamer's bass cut helps humbuckers stay clear under drive, while a Blues Driver flatters single coils. Our Blues Driver vs Tube Screamer vs Klon comparison explains which drive pedal pairs best with each type.

Matching Pickups to Your Music

Indie and jangly pop. Single coils, especially on a Tele or Jazzmaster style guitar. The clarity helps chords and arpeggios cut through.

Funk and soul. Single coils. The quick attack makes tight rhythm parts snap.

Blues. Either. Strat blues and Les Paul blues are both classic sounds. Choose by the players you love.

Country. Single coils, usually a Telecaster bridge pickup, for that bright twang.

Classic rock. Humbuckers for the big riff sound; a Strat for the more open sound of other classic rock records.

Metal. Humbuckers, usually higher output models designed for high gain.

Jazz. Traditionally humbuckers in the neck position for a warm, round tone.

Songwriting. As a songwriter, I find the type of guitar shapes the type of song. Single coils encourage open chords and space. Humbuckers encourage riffs and power. Neither is better, but it is worth knowing which direction your instrument pulls you.

Getting Both Sounds in One Guitar

You do not always have to choose.

HSS layouts. Many Strats put a humbucker in the bridge position and single coils in the middle and neck. You get rock grunt at the bridge and Strat sparkle elsewhere. The Squier Sonic Stratocaster HSS is an inexpensive example.

Coil splitting. Some humbuckers can be wired to switch off one coil, giving a thinner, brighter single coil style sound. It needs a pickup with four conductor wiring and a switch, often a push pull pot. A split humbucker is not identical to a true single coil, but it is a useful extra colour.

Noiseless single coils. Some single coil sized pickups are designed to cancel hum while keeping much of the single coil character. Fender's Noiseless range is the best known. They suit players who love single coils but play with gain or in noisy venues.

If you like the idea of two humbuckers on a lighter, Strat style body with 24 frets, Fency Music, our sister store, carries the Farida MA-3 Modern Artist Super Strat, a dual humbucker guitar with a 25.5 inch scale and a fixed bridge.

Practical Tips for Either Type

Set the pickup height. Pickups that sit too close to the strings can sound harsh and, with strong magnets, even pull the strings out of tune. Too far away and they sound weak. Our guide on how to set up a cheap guitar explains how to adjust height.

Reduce hum with single coils. Face a different direction, move away from computers and dimmers, and use the hum cancelling in between positions where you can.

Use your volume knob. Both types clean up when you roll the volume back, and a guitar with good pots keeps its brightness while you do it.

Match the amp. Bright amps flatter humbuckers; warmer amps flatter single coils. If you are still choosing, our best practice amps roundup and Blues Junior vs Princeton Reverb comparison are good starting points.

Record both. If you are deciding between guitars, record a short clip of the same riff on each. Our guide to recording guitar at home shows the simplest way. Listening back is often clearer than playing in a shop.

What I Don't Like About Each Type

Single coils. The hum is real, especially with gain or near computers. The cheapest ceramic single coils can sound harsh and thin. And they rarely give you the thick, saturated lead sound that heavier rock needs without help from pedals.

Humbuckers. Clean chords can sound woolly, and they lose some of the sparkle that makes single coil guitars so lively. High output humbuckers can compress your playing so much that light and hard picking sound similar.

Both. Pickup talk can become an endless chase. A new set of pickups will not fix a badly set up guitar, a poor amp or tired strings. Fix those first.

Who Should Skip the Debate

FAQ

Are humbuckers better than single coils?

No, humbuckers are not better, just different. Humbuckers suit heavier, thicker sounds and stay quiet under high gain. Single coils suit bright, clear, detailed sounds and clean or lightly driven tones. The right choice depends on your music, your amp and the players whose sound you want to get close to.

Can I put a humbucker in a single coil guitar?

Sometimes, yes. Many Strat style guitars can take a humbucker in the bridge if the body is routed for it, and some humbuckers are made in single coil size. Otherwise the body needs routing and the scratchplate changing. A guitar technician can tell you what fits before you buy anything.

Why does my single coil guitar hum?

Your single coil guitar hums because a single coil picks up electrical interference as well as the strings. Computers, dimmer switches, fridges and lighting are common causes. Moving or turning away from them helps. The in between positions on a Strat usually cancel most of the hum, and noiseless pickups reduce it further.

Are P90s single coils or humbuckers?

P90s are single coil pickups. They are wider than Fender style single coils and use more wire, so they sound thicker and grittier, somewhere between a Strat pickup and a humbucker. Because they have only one coil, they still pick up hum, especially with high gain.

Which pickups are best for a beginner?

Either type is fine for a beginner. Choose the guitar that matches the music you want to play. An HSS Strat is a sensible middle ground, with a humbucker for rock and single coils for clean tones, and it is usually cheaper than a Les Paul style guitar.

The Bottom End

Single coils and humbuckers are two different voices, not a good option and a bad one. Single coils give you brightness, clarity and sparkle, with a little hum as the price. Humbuckers give you warmth, weight and quiet power, with a little less detail. Think about the songs you want to write and the records you love, then pick the voice that fits. And if you cannot choose, a guitar with both is a perfectly good answer.